Naghavi, Mohsen and Vollset, Stein Emil and Ikuta, Kevin S and Swetschinski, Lucien R and Gray, Authia P and Wool, Eve E and Robles Aguilar, Gisela and Mestrovic, Tomislav and Smith, Georgia and Han, Chieh and Hsu, Rebecca L and Chalek, Julian and Araki, Daniel T and Chung, Erin and Raggi, Catalina and Gershberg Hayoon, Anna and Davis Weaver, Nicole and Lindstedt, Paulina A and Smith, Amanda E and Altay, Umut and Bhattacharjee, Natalia V and Giannakis, Konstantinos and Fell, Frederick and McManigal, Barney and Ekapirat, Nattwut and Mendes, Jessica Andretta and Runghien, Tilleye and Srimokla, Oraya and Abdelkader, Atef and Abd-Elsalam, Sherief and Aboagye, Richard Gyan and Abolhassani, Hassan and Abualruz, Hasan and Abubakar, Usman and Abukhadijah, Hana J and Aburuz, Salahdein and Abu-Zaid, Ahmed and Achalapong, Sureerak and Addo, Isaac Yeboah and Adekanmbi, Victor and Adeyeoluwa, Temitayo Esther and Adnani, Qorinah Estiningtyas Sakilah and Adzigbli, Leticia Akua and Afzal, Muhammad Sohail and Afzal, Saira and Agodi, Antonella and Ahlstrom, Austin J and Ahmad, Aqeel and Ahmad, Sajjad and Ahmad, Tauseef and Ahmadi, Ali and Ahmed, Ayman and Ahmed, Haroon and Ahmed, Ibrar and Ahmed, Mohammed and Ahmed, Saeed and Ahmed, Syed Anees and Akkaif, Mohammed Ahmed and Al Awaidy, Salah and Al Thaher, Yazan and Alalalmeh, Samer O and AlBataineh, Mohammad T and Aldhaleei, Wafa A and Al-Gheethi, Adel Ali Saeed and Alhaji, Nma Bida and Ali, Abid and Ali, Liaqat and Ali, Syed Shujait and Ali, Waad and Allel, Kasim and Al-Marwani, Sabah and Alrawashdeh, Ahmad and Altaf, Awais and Al-Tammemi, Alaa B. and Al-Tawfiq, Jaffar A and Alzoubi, Karem H and Al-Zyoud, Walid Adnan and Amos, Ben and Amuasi, John H and Ancuceanu, Robert and Andrews, Jason R and Anil, Abhishek and Anuoluwa, Iyadunni Adesola and Anvari, Saeid and Anyasodor, Anayochukwu Edward and Apostol, Geminn Louis Carace and Arabloo, Jalal and Arafat, Mosab and Aravkin, Aleksandr Y and Areda, Demelash and Aremu, Abdulfatai and Artamonov, Anton A and Ashley, Elizabeth A and Asika, Marvellous O and Athari, Seyyed Shamsadin and Atout, Maha Moh'd Wahbi and Awoke, Tewachew and Azadnajafabad, Sina and Azam, James Mba and Aziz, Shahkaar and Azzam, Ahmed Y. and Babaei, Mahsa and Babin, Francois-Xavier and Badar, Muhammad and Baig, Atif Amin and Bajcetic, Milica and Baker, Stephen and Bardhan, Mainak and Barqawi, Hiba Jawdat and Basharat, Zarrin and Basiru, Afisu and Bastard, Mathieu and Basu, Saurav and Bayleyegn, Nebiyou Simegnew and Belete, Melaku Ashagrie and Bello, Olorunjuwon Omolaja and Beloukas, Apostolos and Berkley, James A and Bhagavathula, Akshaya Srikanth and Bhaskar, Sonu and Bhuyan, Soumitra S and Bielicki, Julia A and Briko, Nikolay Ivanovich and Brown, Colin Stewart and Browne, Annie J and Buonsenso, Danilo and Bustanji, Yasser and Carvalheiro, Cristina G and Castañeda-Orjuela, Carlos A and Cenderadewi, Muthia and Chadwick, Joshua and Chakraborty, Sandip and Chandika, Rama Mohan and Chandy, Sara and Chansamouth, Vilada and Chattu, Vijay Kumar and Chaudhary, Anis Ahmad and Ching, Patrick R and Chopra, Hitesh and Chowdhury, Fazle Rabbi and Chu, Dinh-Toi and Chutiyami, Muhammad and Cruz-Martins, Natalia and da Silva, Alanna Gomes and Dadras, Omid and Dai, Xiaochen and Darcho, Samuel D and Das, Saswati and De la Hoz, Fernando Pio and Dekker, Denise Myriam and Dhama, Kuldeep and Diaz, Daniel and Dickson, Benjamin Felix Rothschild and Djorie, Serge Ghislain and Dodangeh, Milad and Dohare, Sushil and Dokova, Klara Georgieva and Doshi, Ojas Prakashbhai and Dowou, Robert Kokou and Dsouza, Haneil Larson and Dunachie, Susanna J and Dziedzic, Arkadiusz Marian and Eckmanns, Tim and Ed-Dra, Abdelaziz and Eftekharimehrabad, Aziz and Ekundayo, Temitope Cyrus and El Sayed, Iman and Elhadi, Muhammed and El-Huneidi, Waseem and Elias, Christelle and Ellis, Sally J and Elsheikh, Randa and Elsohaby, Ibrahim and Eltaha, Chadi and Eshrati, Babak and Eslami, Majid and Eyre, David William and Fadaka, Adewale Oluwaseun and Fagbamigbe, Adeniyi Francis and Fahim, Ayesha and Fakhri-Demeshghieh, Aliasghar and Fasina, Folorunso Oludayo and Fasina, Modupe Margaret and Fatehizadeh, Ali and Feasey, Nicholas A and Feizkhah, Alireza and Fekadu, Ginenus and Fischer, Florian and Fitriana, Ida and Forrest, Karen M and Fortuna Rodrigues, Celia and Fuller, John E and Gadanya, Muktar A and Gajdács, Márió and Gandhi, Aravind P and Garcia-Gallo, Esteban E and Garrett, Denise O and Gautam, Rupesh K and Gebregergis, Miglas Welay and Gebrehiwot, Mesfin and Gebremeskel, Teferi Gebru and Geffers, Christine and Georgalis, Leonidas and Ghazy, Ramy Mohamed and Golechha, Mahaveer and Golinelli, Davide and Gordon, Melita and Gulati, Snigdha and Gupta, Rajat Das and Gupta, Sapna and Gupta, Vijai Kumar and Habteyohannes, Awoke Derbie and Haller, Sebastian and Harapan, Harapan and Harrison, Michelle L and Hasaballah, Ahmed I and Hasan, Ikramul and Hasan, Rumina Syeda and Hasani, Hamidreza and Haselbeck, Andrea Haekyung and Hasnain, Md Saquib and Hassan, Ikrama Ibrahim and Hassan, Shoaib and Hassan Zadeh Tabatabaei, Mahgol Sadat and Hayat, Khezar and He, Jiawei and Hegazi, Omar E and Heidari, Mohammad and Hezam, Kamal and Holla, Ramesh and Holm, Marianne and Hopkins, Heidi and Hossain, Md Mahbub and Hosseinzadeh, Mehdi and Hostiuc, Sorin and Hussein, Nawfal R and Huy, Le Duc and Ibáñez-Prada, Elsa D and Ikiroma, Adalia and Ilic, Irena M and Islam, Sheikh Mohammed Shariful and Ismail, Faisal and Ismail, Nahlah Elkudssiah and Iwu, Chidozie Declan and Iwu-Jaja, Chinwe Juliana and Jafarzadeh, Abdollah and Jaiteh, Fatoumatta and Jalilzadeh Yengejeh, Reza and Jamora, Roland Dominic G and Javidnia, Javad and Jawaid, Talha and Jenney, Adam W J and Jeon, Hyon Jin and Jokar, Mohammad and Jomehzadeh, Nabi and Joo, Tamas and Joseph, Nitin and Kamal, Zul and Kanmodi, Kehinde Kazeem and Kantar, Rami S and Kapisi, James Apollo and Karaye, Ibraheem M and Khader, Yousef Saleh and Khajuria, Himanshu and Khalid, Nauman and Khamesipour, Faham and Khan, Ajmal and Khan, Mohammad Jobair and Khan, Muhammad Tariq and Khanal, Vishnu and Khidri, Feriha Fatima and Khubchandani, Jagdish and Khusuwan, Suwimon and Kim, Min Seo and Kisa, Adnan and Korshunov, Vladimir Andreevich and Krapp, Fiorella and Krumkamp, Ralf and Kuddus, Mohammed and Kulimbet, Mukhtar and Kumar, Dewesh and Kumaran, Emmanuelle A P and Kuttikkattu, Ambily and Kyu, Hmwe Hmwe and Landires, Iván and Lawal, Basira Kankia and Le, Thao Thi Thu and Lederer, Ingeborg Maria and Lee, Munjae and Lee, Seung Won and Lepape, Alain and Lerango, Temesgen Leka and Ligade, Virendra S and Lim, Cherry and Lim, Stephen S and Limenh, Liknaw Workie and Liu, Chaojie and Liu, Xiaofeng and Liu, Xuefeng and Loftus, Michael J and M Amin, Hawraz Ibrahim and Maass, Kelsey Lynn and Maharaj, Sandeep B and Mahmoud, Mansour Adam and Maikanti-Charalampous, Panagiota and Makram, Omar M and Malhotra, Kashish and Malik, Ahmad Azam and Mandilara, Georgia D and Marks, Florian and Martinez-Guerra, Bernardo Alfonso and Martorell, Miquel and Masoumi-Asl, Hossein and Mathioudakis, Alexander G and May, Juergen and McHugh, Theresa A and Meiring, James and Meles, Hadush Negash and Melese, Addisu and Melese, Endalkachew Belayneh and Minervini, Giuseppe and Mohamed, Nouh Saad and Mohammed, Shafiu and Mohan, Syam and Mokdad, Ali H and Monasta, Lorenzo and Moodi Ghalibaf, AmirAli and Moore, Catrin E and Moradi, Yousef and Mossialos, Elias and Mougin, Vincent and Mukoro, George Duke and Mulita, Francesk and Muller-Pebody, Berit and Murillo-Zamora, Efren and Musa, Sani and Musicha, Patrick and Musila, Lillian A and Muthupandian, Saravanan and Nagarajan, Ahamarshan Jayaraman and Naghavi, Pirouz and Nainu, Firzan and Nair, Tapas Sadasivan and Najmuldeen, Hastyar Hama Rashid and Natto, Zuhair S and Nauman, Javaid and Nayak, Biswa Prakash and Nchanji, G Takop and Ndishimye, Pacifique and Negoi, Ionut and Negoi, Ruxandra Irina and Nejadghaderi, Seyed Aria and Nguyen, QuynhAnh P and Noman, Efaq Ali and Nwakanma, Davis C and O'Brien, Seamus and Ochoa, Theresa J and Odetokun, Ismail A and Ogundijo, Oluwaseun Adeolu and Ojo-Akosile, Tolulope R and Okeke, Sylvester Reuben and Okonji, Osaretin Christabel and Olagunju, Andrew T and Olivas-Martinez, Antonio and Olorukooba, Abdulhakeem Abayomi and Olwoch, Peter and Onyedibe, Kenneth Ikenna and Ortiz-Brizuela, Edgar and Osuolale, Olayinka and Ounchanum, Pradthana and Oyeyemi, Oyetunde T and P A, Mahesh Padukudru and Paredes, Jose L and Parikh, Romil R and Patel, Jay and Patil, Shankargouda and Pawar, Shrikant and Peleg, Anton Y and Peprah, Prince and Perdigão, João and Perrone, Carlo and Petcu, Ionela-Roxana and Phommasone, Koukeo and Piracha, Zahra Zahid and Poddighe, Dimitri and Pollard, Andrew J and Poluru, Ramesh and Ponce-De-Leon, Alfredo and Puvvula, Jagadeesh and Qamar, Farah Naz and Qasim, Nameer Hashim and Rafai, Clotaire Donatien and Raghav, Pankaja and Rahbarnia, Leila and Rahim, Fakher and Rahimi-Movaghar, Vafa and Rahman, Mosiur and Rahman, Muhammad Aziz and Ramadan, Hazem and Ramasamy, Shakthi Kumaran and Ramesh, Pushkal Sinduvadi and Ramteke, Pramod W and Rana, Rishabh Kumar and Rani, Usha and Rashidi, Mohammad-Mahdi and Rathish, Devarajan and Rattanavong, Sayaphet and Rawaf, Salman and Redwan, Elrashdy Moustafa Mohamed and Reyes, Luis Felipe and Roberts, Tamalee and Robotham, Julie V and Rosenthal, Victor Daniel and Ross, Allen Guy and Roy, Nitai and Rudd, Kristina E and Sabet, Cameron John and Saddik, Basema Ahmad and Saeb, Mohammad Reza and Saeed, Umar and Saeedi Moghaddam, Sahar and Saengchan, Weeravoot and Safaei, Mohsen and Saghazadeh, Amene and Saheb Sharif-Askari, Narjes and Sahebkar, Amirhossein and Sahoo, Soumya Swaroop and Sahu, Maitreyi and Saki, Morteza and Salam, Nasir and Saleem, Zikria and Saleh, Mohamed A and Samodra, Yoseph Leonardo and Samy, Abdallah M and Saravanan, Aswini and Satpathy, Maheswar and Schumacher, Austin E and Sedighi, Mansour and Seekaew, Samroeng and Shafie, Mahan and Shah, Pritik A and Shahid, Samiah and Shahwan, Moyad Jamal and Shakoor, Sadia and Shalev, Noga and Shamim, Muhammad Aaqib and Shamshirgaran, Mohammad Ali and Shamsi, Anas and Sharifan, Amin and Shastry, Rajesh P and Shetty, Mahabalesh and Shittu, Aminu and Shrestha, Sunil and Siddig, Emmanuel Edwar and Sideroglou, Theologia and Sifuentes-Osornio, Jose and Silva, Luís Manuel Lopes Rodrigues and Simões, Eric A F and Simpson, Andrew J H and Singh, Amit and Singh, Surjit and Sinto, Robert and Soliman, Sameh S M and Soraneh, Soroush and Stoesser, Nicole and Stoeva, Temenuga Zhekova and Swain, Chandan Kumar and Szarpak, Lukasz and T Y, Sree Sudha and Tabatabai, Shima and Tabche, Celine and Taha, Zanan Mohammed-Ameen and Tan, Ker-Kan and Tasak, Nidanuch and Tat, Nathan Y and Thaiprakong, Areerat and Thangaraju, Pugazhenthan and Tigoi, Caroline Chepngeno and Tiwari, Krishna and Tovani-Palone, Marcos Roberto and Tran, Thang Huu and Tumurkhuu, Munkhtuya and Turner, Paul and Udoakang, Aniefiok John and Udoh, Arit and Ullah, Noor and Ullah, Saeed and Vaithinathan, Asokan Govindaraj and Valenti, Mario and Vos, Theo and Vu, Huong T L and Waheed, Yasir and Walker, Ann Sarah and Walson, Judd L and Wangrangsimakul, Tri and Weerakoon, Kosala Gayan and Wertheim, Heiman F L and Williams, Phoebe C M and Wolde, Asrat Arja and Wozniak, Teresa M and Wu, Felicia and Wu, Zenghong and Yadav, Mukesh Kumar Kumar and Yaghoubi, Sajad and Yahaya, Zwanden Sule and Yarahmadi, Amir and Yezli, Saber and Yismaw, Yazachew Engida and Yon, Dong Keon and Yuan, Chun-Wei and Yusuf, Hadiza and Zakham, Fathiah and Zamagni, Giulia and Zhang, Haijun and Zhang, Zhi-Jiang and Zielińska, Magdalena and Zumla, Alimuddin and Zyoud, Sa'ed H. H and Zyoud, Samer H and Hay, Simon I and Stergachis, Andy and Sartorius, Benn and Cooper, Ben S and Dolecek, Christiane and Murray, Christopher J L (2024) Global Burden of Bacterial Antimicrobial Resistance 1990–2021: A Systematic Analysis with Forecasts To 2050. The Lancet, 404 (10459). pp. 1199-1226. ISSN 01406736
![[thumbnail of Research Article]](https://eprints.cihanuniversity.edu.iq/style/images/fileicons/text.png)
Article_L_16-09-2024.pdf - Published Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.
Download (3MB)
Abstract
Background
Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) poses an important global health challenge in the 21st century. A previous study has quantified the global and regional burden of AMR for 2019, followed with additional publications that provided more detailed estimates for several WHO regions by country. To date, there have been no studies that produce comprehensive estimates of AMR burden across locations that encompass historical trends and future forecasts.
Methods
We estimated all-age and age-specific deaths and disability-adjusted life-years (DALYs) attributable to and associated with bacterial AMR for 22 pathogens, 84 pathogen–drug combinations, and 11 infectious syndromes in 204 countries and territories from 1990 to 2021. We collected and used multiple cause of death data, hospital discharge data, microbiology data, literature studies, single drug resistance profiles, pharmaceutical sales, antibiotic use surveys, mortality surveillance, linkage data, outpatient and inpatient insurance claims data, and previously published data, covering 520 million individual records or isolates and 19 513 study-location-years. We used statistical modelling to produce estimates of AMR burden for all locations, including those with no data. Our approach leverages the estimation of five broad component quantities: the number of deaths involving sepsis; the proportion of infectious deaths attributable to a given infectious syndrome; the proportion of infectious syndrome deaths attributable to a given pathogen; the percentage of a given pathogen resistant to an antibiotic of interest; and the excess risk of death or duration of an infection associated with this resistance. Using these components, we estimated disease burden attributable to and associated with AMR, which we define based on two counterfactuals; respectively, an alternative scenario in which all drug-resistant infections are replaced by drug-susceptible infections, and an alternative scenario in which all drug-resistant infections were replaced by no infection. Additionally, we produced global and regional forecasts of AMR burden until 2050 for three scenarios: a reference scenario that is a probabilistic forecast of the most likely future; a Gram-negative drug scenario that assumes future drug development that targets Gram-negative pathogens; and a better care scenario that assumes future improvements in health-care quality and access to appropriate antimicrobials. We present final estimates aggregated to the global, super-regional, and regional level.
Findings
In 2021, we estimated 4·71 million (95% UI 4·23–5·19) deaths were associated with bacterial AMR, including 1·14 million (1·00–1·28) deaths attributable to bacterial AMR. Trends in AMR mortality over the past 31 years varied substantially by age and location. From 1990 to 2021, deaths from AMR decreased by more than 50% among children younger than 5 years yet increased by over 80% for adults 70 years and older. AMR mortality decreased for children younger than 5 years in all super-regions, whereas AMR mortality in people 5 years and older increased in all super-regions. For both deaths associated with and deaths attributable to AMR, meticillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus increased the most globally (from 261 000 associated deaths [95% UI 150 000–372 000] and 57 200 attributable deaths [34 100–80 300] in 1990, to 550 000 associated deaths [500 000–600 000] and 130 000 attributable deaths [113 000–146 000] in 2021). Among Gram-negative bacteria, resistance to carbapenems increased more than any other antibiotic class, rising from 619 000 associated deaths (405 000–834 000) in 1990, to 1·03 million associated deaths (909 000–1·16 million) in 2021, and from 127 000 attributable deaths (82 100–171 000) in 1990, to 216 000 (168 000–264 000) attributable deaths in 2021. There was a notable decrease in non-COVID-related infectious disease in 2020 and 2021. Our forecasts show that an estimated 1·91 million (1·56–2·26) deaths attributable to AMR and 8·22 million (6·85–9·65) deaths associated with AMR could occur globally in 2050. Super-regions with the highest all-age AMR mortality rate in 2050 are forecasted to be south Asia and Latin America and the Caribbean. Increases in deaths attributable to AMR will be largest among those 70 years and older (65·9% [61·2–69·8] of all-age deaths attributable to AMR in 2050). In stark contrast to the strong increase in number of deaths due to AMR of 69·6% (51·5–89·2) from 2022 to 2050, the number of DALYs showed a much smaller increase of 9·4% (–6·9 to 29·0) to 46·5 million (37·7 to 57·3) in 2050. Under the better care scenario, across all age groups, 92·0 million deaths (82·8–102·0) could be cumulatively averted between 2025 and 2050, through better care of severe infections and improved access to antibiotics, and under the Gram-negative drug scenario, 11·1 million AMR deaths (9·08–13·2) could be averted through the development of a Gram-negative drug pipeline to prevent AMR deaths.
Interpretation
This study presents the first comprehensive assessment of the global burden of AMR from 1990 to 2021, with results forecasted until 2050. Evaluating changing trends in AMR mortality across time and location is necessary to understand how this important global health threat is developing and prepares us to make informed decisions regarding interventions. Our findings show the importance of infection prevention, as shown by the reduction of AMR deaths in those younger than 5 years. Simultaneously, our results underscore the concerning trend of AMR burden among those older than 70 years, alongside a rapidly ageing global community. The opposing trends in the burden of AMR deaths between younger and older individuals explains the moderate future increase in global number of DALYs versus number of deaths. Given the high variability of AMR burden by location and age, it is important that interventions combine infection prevention, vaccination, minimisation of inappropriate antibiotic use in farming and humans, and research into new antibiotics to mitigate the number of AMR deaths that are forecasted for 2050.
Funding
UK Department of Health and Social Care's Fleming Fund using UK aid, and the Wellcome Trust.
Item Type: | Article |
---|---|
Uncontrolled Keywords: | Global Burden, Bacterial Antimicrobial Resistance (Amr) , Systematic Analysis , 1990–2021 , Forecasts , 2050 |
Subjects: | R Medicine > RA Public aspects of medicine |
Divisions: | Department of Medical Biochemical Analysis > Research papers |
Depositing User: | ePrints Depositor |
Date Deposited: | 21 Nov 2024 07:15 |
Last Modified: | 21 Nov 2024 07:15 |
URI: | https://eprints.cihanuniversity.edu.iq/id/eprint/2657 |